Should an Islam Class be Taught by an Islamophobe?

Should an Islam Class be Taught by an Islamophobe?
A proposed Islam course at Lane Community College is gaining national controversy as the suppossed anti-Islamic background of the instructor is revealed. Learn more about the sparking debate and the future of the course.

It all started when Lane Community College in Oregon decided to offer a non-credit course titled, "What is Islam?" The instructor of the course, Barry Sommer, had submitted an application to teach a class in Islam for the community college, which the college accepted. However, before the course had a single sign-up, the college put the brakes on the offering. Apparently, officials of the school learned some potentially disturbing facts about Sommer and decided it was best to nip the brewing controversy in the bud.

The Facts

Eugene resident Barry Sommer submitted an application in October of this year to teach a class on Islam at Lane Community College. The school typically offers non-credit courses for interested students throughout the year, and many of these are taught by qualified residents of the community, rather than college professors. According to a report at World Net Daily, approval for the course came, and Sommer began preparations for teaching. When the course went online on the college website, Sommer also sent out a press release to alert others to his offering.

Once the details were announced, a local news station asked to interview Sommer. As the course became more public, so did Sommer's background. It turns out the Sommer may have been involved in organizations that were perceived as anti-Islamic. Once the news spread that Sommer was a potentially controversial figure in the Islamic community, Lane pulled the plug on the course.

This short video offers an overview of Islam.

More about Sommer

According to a report at the Register-Guard, Sommer has given talks at the Pacifica Forum, a discussion group at the University of Oregon that was eventually forced off the campus because some of their discussions were perceived as anti-semitic. Sommer is also the leader of the Oregon chapter of ACT! For America. This organization is described as an issues advocacy group, but some have referred to it as an Islamic hate group instead. An entry on Blogtown at the Portland Mercury also states that Sommer has promoted profiling by the TSA.

To his credit, Sommer is a self-proclaimed expert on Islam, after beginning intense studies on Islam and the Middle East 20 years ago. He has given numerous lectures around his area on Islam, so he believes he has the necessary credentials to teach the course at Lane. Sommer submitted a syllabus for the course along with his application, so the school knew what he was planning to teach in his class.

Sommer said he is disappointed in the way the college handled the situation and is currently pursuing legal action because he believes his free speech rights have been violated. He has retained the services of the American Center of Law and Justice, a non-profit law firm founded by televangelist Pat Robertson. Sommer insists that the purpose of his course was education, rather than indoctrination, and he thought students should be presented with the facts about Islam so they could draw their own conclusions.

This video offers another overview of Islam.

What Lane has to Say

LCC President Mary Spilde said she first learned of Sommer's background when the media caught wind of the course offering. She did not know whether the college officials that originally scheduled the course were aware of Sommer's background, but said that it is not common practice for the school to require non-credit course teachers to have the same credentials as the college professors on staff.

Spilde said once she knew of Sommer's potential controversy, she took action. She told the Register-Guard, "When it got on our radar, given the recent events in Portland and Corvallis, we said, 'Wait a minute, we need to be very careful and really consider how Lane engages learning experiences in this environment." Spilde was specifically referring to the Muslim man recently arrested in downtown Portland and the subsequent arson at the Corvallis mosque.

This video purports to explain Islam.

Spilde acknowledged that after Sommer's course offering was made public, the community college was contacted by the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), the country's largest Muslim civil liberties advocacy organization. Arsalan Bukhari, executive director of the Washington chapter of CAIR, told the Register-Guard, "Unless the goal of this course is to promote anti-Muslim bigotry, Lane Community College should replace Mr. Sommer with someone who will offer students a balanced and objective analysis of the subject matter." Spilde said that the course had been canceled prior to CAIR's contact.

"We certainly value intellectual inquiry and freedom of speech but we also want to make sure, when LCC is involved, that we are doing it in an appropriate way to provide a productive and effective learning environment," Spilde said. "We are not going to be pressured by any group on any side of this issue when we make a decision."

Questions? Contact us on Facebook. @communitycollegereview

Additional Resources [+]
comments powered by Disqus

Recent Articles

Retaining Students through Innovation
Retaining Students through Innovation
Community colleges are heeding President Obama's call for student retention. Learn about the innovative programs some community campuses are creating that keep students in their classroom seats.
Community Colleges Fight Back Against For-Profit Attacks: The Rebuttal
Community Colleges Fight Back Against For-Profit Attacks: The Rebuttal
After being attacked by private colleges, community colleges are mounting a defense and publishing studies that clearly outline the differences between the public and private institutions.
A to Z of Community College Certificates and Courses
June 17, 2024
A to Z of Community College Certificates and Courses
From business and healthcare to technology and skilled trades, the article showcases the breadth of options available to students seeking to enhance their knowledge, develop new skills, or pursue career advancement.

Get Your Degree!

Find schools and get information on the program that’s right for you.

Powered by Campus Explorer

Courses in College