Should Community Colleges Allow Undocumented Immigrants to Enroll?

Should Community Colleges Allow Undocumented Immigrants to Enroll?
Learn about the controversy surrounding community colleges' admission policies regarding undocumented immigrants.
Community colleges were intended to help all students access higher education, regardless of socioeconomic or geographical constraints.  Subsequently, some community colleges have adjusted their admission policies, allowing undocumented immigrants to enroll on campus.             
 
However, these changes have been met with great controversy, especially during a time when community colleges are facing record high enrollment rates.  In particular, North Carolina has been battered with an array of protestors who argue that community colleges are already struggling to provide for its massive number of documented, legal students.  In light of these enrollment demands, how can community colleges accommodate undocumented students? 
 
As the debate continues to rage on both sides, some experts predict that community colleges across the country will soon feel pressured to permit undocumented immigrants into their classrooms. 
 
Undocumented Students: The Heated Debate
 
Examining these controversial changes to community college policies in North Carolina, WRAL News reports that all community colleges in the state must accept qualified illegal immigrants if the applicants meet all of the admission guidelines.  Prior to this new policy, college officials were required to reject any undocumented students, even if the applicants were over the age of 18 and had earned a high school diploma in the United States. 
 
How did the policy shift so dramatically?  In 1997, Mike Easley, former Attorney General and Mayor of North Carolina, expressed his support in allowing undocumented immigrants to enroll in community colleges.  A lawyer, speaking on behalf of the entire North Carolina Community College Network, ordered each of the state’s 58 community college campuses to comply with Easley’s decree. 
 
As many North Carolina residents were surprised to learn, approximately half of the state’s community college campuses already permitted certain students without proof of citizenship to enroll.   However, other campuses were forced to shift their enrollment policies.  For example, Wake Technical Community College, located in Raleigh, previously required all student applicants to prove their legal residency, but were now mandated to enroll all qualified students, regardless of their immigration status. 
 
Critics of the policy argue that the government is taking away the individual rights of each college campus.  Adding to the tension, the North Carolina policy is not being well received by voices from national leaders, including various US representatives and senators.  One of the outspoken critics of this policy was US Representative Sue Myrick, a Republican of North Carolina.  According to Myrick, “Our community colleges are supposed to educate and train American citizens to enter the work force. But North Carolina wants to educate and train illegal aliens so they can directly compete against American citizens for the same jobs? That is just plain wrong.” 
 
The Benefits of Undocumented Student Enrollment
 
Supporters of the new policy assert that accepting illegal immigrants into community college programs will serve to benefit the overall economy and success of the state.  First and foremost, the community college can charge a very high tuition rate for undocumented workers.  Essentially, students who attend a community college from another state, or in this case, another country, must pay a much more expensive “out of state” tuition fee.  As a result, if an undocumented individual wanted to apply for classes at Wake Technical Community College, then he or she would be forced to pay an out of state tuition fee of approximately $7,000 to $10,000.  As a result of these out of state charges, supporters assert that community colleges could earn, on average, an extra $2,000 for each undocumented student that is enrolled for a full class schedule.  With the higher tuition revenues, schools may be able to improve their budgets despite a struggling economy.
 
Many immigration activist groups have also gathered to speak in favor of the new North Carolina community college policy changes.  For example, leaders of “El Pueblo,” a Latino advocacy group, assert that allowing undocumented immigrants to enroll in college courses will provide generations of individuals with greater opportunities to advance and thrive.  As many undocumented individuals were brought by parents to the United States, often as young children or infants, denying students the chance to continue their education would be seen as an unjust punishment for a crime that many never chose to commit.          
 
The debate regarding enrolling undocumented immigrants into community colleges will certainly continue to rage.  Especially during a time when documented students are being forced onto waiting lists, there is a strong wall of opposition against the policy changes.  However, the opposition is met with an equal force of support who believe in allowing all students access to higher education.

Additional Resources [+]
Stuck on a Waiting List? How Community College Students Can Combat College Admission Freezes
Stuck on a Waiting List? How Community College Students Can Combat College Admission Freezes
Cosmopolitan Community Colleges: Growth in International Student Enrollment
Cosmopolitan Community Colleges: Growth in International Student Enrollment
comments powered by Disqus
Recent Articles
Undeserved Community College Accreditation:  Abuse of Power?
Undeserved Community College Accreditation: Abuse of Power?
Complaints about the current system of accrediting community colleges, combined with the quickly changing scope of community college education and how it’s delivered, may soon necessitate changes in the way that community college programs are accredited.
Competency-Based Education: Better for Your Academic Success?
In recent years, interest in competency-based education has risen drastically. It is a form of learning in which students engage in self-paced instruction and assessment of aptitudes rather than attending traditional courses and receiving traditional grades. Seen as the future of community college education by some, and as a cheapened version of a real education by others, competency-based education appears to be here to stay.
Graduate from Community College Before High School
High school students across the nation are enrolling in college credit classes and finding that graduating from college before even graduating from high school is a very real possibility.

Get Your Degree!

Find schools and get information on the program that’s right for you.

Powered by Campus Explorer

Why Community College

ENROLLMENT & ADMISSIONS

We provide a comprehensive look into some of the most important issues affecting enrollment and admissions. Get the latest news on declining enrollment across the country and the impact it has. Learn more about the latest trends in admissions requirements from vaccinations to placement tests. Find expert advice on what to expect your first year, and lean more about the pitfalls to avoid.